Homeowners Insurance Florida - How Hard Is It To Get in 2026?

Homeowners Insurance Florida - How Hard Is It To Get in 2026?

If you’re buying a home in Southwest Florida right now, there’s one question that can derail your entire purchase faster than a failed inspection: can you actually get homeowners insurance? It’s a fair question. Florida has spent the last several years in the grip of a full-blown insurance crisis that drove premiums to record highs, forced dozens of carriers out of the state, and left hundreds of thousands of homeowners scrambling for coverage. But here’s the good news heading into 2026 — the market is finally stabilizing, and getting homeowners insurance in Florida is becoming more manageable than it’s been in years.

That doesn’t mean it’s easy. Especially in Southwest Florida communities like Cape Coral, Fort Myers, Naples, and the barrier islands, there are still real challenges. Your roof age, your proximity to the Gulf, your flood zone, and even your credit score all play a role in whether an insurer will write your policy — and what you’ll pay for it.

This guide breaks down everything you need to know about the current state of homeowners insurance in Florida — what it costs, why it’s been so difficult to obtain, what’s changing in 2026, and the specific strategies that will help you lock down coverage if you’re buying in Southwest Florida.

What Caused the Florida Homeowners Insurance Crisis?

To understand how hard it is to get homeowners insurance in Florida today, you need to understand what went wrong. The crisis didn’t appear overnight. It was the result of several colliding forces that turned Florida into the most expensive — and most volatile — insurance market in the country.

Hurricanes and Catastrophic Losses

Florida gets hit by more named storms than any other state. Major hurricanes like Andrew (1992), the devastating 2004–2005 season, Irma (2017), Michael (2018), and Ian (2022) caused hundreds of billions in insured losses over the past three decades. Hurricane Ian alone produced $2.39 billion in residential insured losses in Southwest Florida, with Hurricane Helene adding another $496.8 million to the tally.

Every major storm cycle drives up the cost of reinsurance — which is essentially insurance that insurers buy to protect themselves. Reinsurance costs consume roughly 30% to 50% of what you pay in premiums. When those costs spike, your premium goes up.

Excessive Litigation and Fraud

Florida accounts for just 9% of all homeowners insurance claims nationwide, but it generates a staggering 79% of all property insurance lawsuits in the entire country. That imbalance was the single biggest driver of insurer losses and market instability. Fraudulent roof-replacement schemes and abusive assignment-of-benefits (AOB) practices drained carriers of billions.

The legal costs insurers faced in Florida were often higher than the cost of actually paying out legitimate claims. That dynamic forced companies to either raise premiums dramatically, stop writing new policies, or leave the state entirely.

Insurer Exits and Insolvencies

Between 2020 and 2024, Florida’s insurance market experienced a wave of company failures that left homeowners with fewer and fewer options:

- Six property insurers became insolvent in 2022 alone
- 14 additional insurers entered liquidation as of October 2025
- More than 300 insurance companies have completed the receivership process in Florida over the years
- Major national carriers like Farmers and Progressive Home pulled back or stopped writing new policies in the state

This exodus left many homeowners with no private market options, forcing them into Citizens Property Insurance — the state-created “insurer of last resort.” Citizens’ policy count surged to a peak of over 1.4 million policies in 2023, a clear sign the private market was failing.

How Hard Is It To Get Homeowners Insurance in Florida Right Now?

The honest answer: it depends on where you’re buying, what the home looks like, and when it was built. For many buyers in Southwest Florida, finding insurance isn’t impossible in 2026 — but it still requires work, patience, and sometimes creativity.

Here’s a snapshot of what different types of buyers and properties are experiencing:

Property Type / SituationDifficulty LevelWhat to ExpectNewer home (built 2002+), inland, updated roofModerateMultiple carrier options; competitive quotes availableOlder home (pre-2002), roof 10+ years oldHighFewer options; may need roof replacement before quotesCoastal / barrier island propertyVery HighLimited carriers; premiums 2–3x inland ratesHome with prior hurricane claimsVery HighNon-renewals common; may need Citizens InsuranceNew construction with impact windows/doorsLowerBest rates available; most carriers competing for theseCondo unit in older buildingHighDepends heavily on HOA master policy and roof condition

If you’re purchasing a newer, well-maintained home with an updated roof in an inland area of Lee, Collier, or Charlotte County, you’ll likely find multiple insurers willing to write your policy. If you’re looking at a 1980s-era home on Fort Myers Beach with an older roof, the process becomes much more challenging.

Featured Snippet: Getting homeowners insurance in Florida in 2026 is challenging but improving. After years of carrier exits and skyrocketing premiums, legislative reforms have attracted 17 new insurers to the state and slowed rate increases to under 1% for major carriers. Southwest Florida buyers can expect annual premiums averaging $2,519 in Lee County and $5,604 in Collier County. Homes with updated roofs, impact windows, and inland locations have the best chance of securing competitive coverage from private market insurers.

Homeowners Insurance Costs in Southwest Florida: What You’ll Actually Pay

Florida remains the most expensive state in the nation for homeowners insurance. The statewide average premium stands at approximately $3,748 per year as of late 2025, which is significantly higher than the national average. But that statewide number masks dramatic variation depending on where you live.

Average Annual Premiums by Southwest Florida County
CountyAverage Annual Premium (2025)Lee County (Fort Myers, Cape Coral)$2,519Charlotte County (Punta Gorda, Port Charlotte)$3,212Collier County (Naples, Marco Island)$5,604Monroe County (Florida Keys)$9,058Statewide Average$3,748

Within each county, your actual premium can vary wildly based on your specific situation. In Cape Coral, for example, a typical mainland home might cost $3,700 on the low end, while gulf-access canal properties can run 20–50% higher depending on roof age and distance to open water.

What Drives Your Specific Premium

The price you’ll pay depends on a combination of factors that insurers weigh when calculating your risk:

- Location and flood zone: Homes near the Gulf Coast carry significantly higher wind and flood exposure than inland properties
- Roof age and condition: This is the single biggest factor. A roof older than 15 years can make your home nearly uninsurable in the private market
- Year built and building code era: Homes built after 2002 benefit from Florida’s updated building codes and are far cheaper to insure
- Wind mitigation features: Impact-rated windows, reinforced garage doors, and hurricane clips can slash your premium by up to 50%
- Coverage amount and deductible: Higher dwelling replacement values mean higher premiums; choosing a 5% hurricane deductible vs. 2% significantly affects your rate
- Claims history: A clean five-year claims history can save you $1,600+ annually compared to having two claims on record
- Credit score: Floridians with poor credit pay approximately 47% more than those with good credit — a difference of over $1,200 per year

What’s Changing in the Florida Insurance Market for 2026

The Florida insurance market has turned a significant corner. After years of pain, legislative reforms enacted in 2022 and 2023 are finally producing measurable results. Here’s what’s different heading into 2026:

Rates Are Stabilizing — and Some Are Dropping

The average premium for the largest 16 property insurers in Florida rose less than 1% in 2025 — a dramatic improvement from the double-digit increases homeowners endured in previous years.

Several major carriers have filed for rate reductions heading into 2026:

- State Farm: 10% average rate reduction statewide
- Heritage Property & Casualty: 7–9.6% reductions depending on county
- Florida Peninsula Insurance: 4% average reduction
- Patriot Select Insurance: 3% premium decrease
- Citizens Property Insurance: Recommending a 2.6% statewide average cut, with 60% of customers seeing an average 11.5% decrease

New Insurers Are Entering the Market

Seventeen new insurance companies have entered Florida since the 2022–2023 reforms were enacted. More competition means more options for homeowners and downward pressure on pricing. Some previously hesitant carriers have also resumed writing new policies in the state.

Citizens Insurance Is Shrinking — and That’s a Good Sign

Citizens Property Insurance policies in force dropped to 395,144 as of January 2025 — a 50% reduction from the prior year and the lowest count in 14 years. This represents the largest transition of policies back to the private market in a decade. More than 546,000 policies were moved to private insurers in 2025 alone.

Litigation Is Declining

Thanks to tort reforms that eliminated one-way attorney fees and cracked down on AOB abuse, property and personal lines litigation dropped approximately 25% in the first half of 2025 compared to 2024. This reduction in legal costs is making insurers more willing to write business in Florida.

Southwest Florida Home Insurance: What Buyers Need to Know

If you’re buying in Lee County, Collier County, or Charlotte County, the insurance landscape has some unique characteristics you need to plan for.

Hurricane Ian’s Lingering Impact

Hurricane Ian devastated Southwest Florida in September 2022, and its effects on the insurance market are still being felt. Fort Myers Beach, Sanibel Island, and Pine Island were ground zero, and properties in these areas continue to face the toughest insurance environment in the region.

Home insurance quotes in Southwest Florida more than doubled after Hurricane Ian for many homeowners, according to Habitat for Humanity of Lee and Hendry Counties. While rates have begun moderating, barrier island properties remain expensive to insure.

The Affordability Squeeze

Rising insurance costs are reshaping entire communities across Southwest Florida. Researchers at Florida State University found that a 10% increase in homeowners insurance reduces housing prices by 4.6%. In Lee County, home values in late 2025 were down more than 10% from a year earlier — in part because buyers factor in the total cost of ownership, including insurance.

For buyers, this creates both a challenge and an opportunity. Higher insurance costs mean steeper monthly payments, but softening home prices may offset some of that burden.

Rate Relief Is Coming to Southwest Florida

Insurance industry insiders report that Southwest Florida is seeing 15–20% lower insurance rates year over year as of mid-2025. Some agents are quoting barrier island policies with decreases of up to 25%, while inland properties west of I-75 are seeing flat rates to 10% reductions.

How To Get Homeowners Insurance in Florida: A Step-by-Step Strategy

Don’t wait until you’re under contract to start shopping for insurance. In Florida, smart buyers begin the insurance process the moment they start house hunting. Here’s how to approach it:

- Step 1: Get a roof inspection before you make an offer. The roof is the single most important factor in getting insured. If it’s older than 15 years, expect that you’ll either need a new roof or a very limited pool of insurers willing to quote you.
- Step 2: Work with an independent insurance agent. Independent agents represent multiple carriers and can shop the market for you. In Florida’s fragmented market, this is essential. Don’t rely on a single national carrier.
- Step 3: Get your wind mitigation inspection done early. A wind mitigation report documents your home’s hurricane-resistant features. Florida law requires insurers to offer discounts for verified wind mitigation, and these discounts can reduce your premium by up to 50%.
- Step 4: Budget for both homeowners AND flood insurance. A standard homeowners policy does NOT cover flood damage. If you’re in a FEMA-designated high-risk flood zone, your lender will require a separate flood policy. Even if you’re not in a high-risk zone, flooding is common throughout Southwest Florida.
- Step 5: Explore Citizens Property Insurance as a fallback. If you can’t find coverage in the private market, Citizens Insurance exists as the state-backed insurer of last resort. You’ll need to show that you were unable to secure standard coverage to qualify.
- Step 6: Consider the My Safe Florida Home program. This state-funded program offers free wind mitigation inspections and matching grants of up to $10,000 for hurricane-hardening upgrades. The state contributes $2 for every $1 you spend on eligible improvements.

The My Safe Florida Home Program: Free Money To Lower Your Insurance Costs

One of the best-kept secrets in Florida homeownership is the My Safe Florida Home (MSFH) program — a state-funded initiative that can dramatically reduce your insurance costs while making your home more resilient.

Program Highlights
- $280 million allocated by the Florida Legislature for 2025–2026
- Free wind mitigation inspections by licensed inspectors at no cost to homeowners
- Matching grants up to $10,000 — the state pays $2 for every $1 you spend on eligible upgrades
- Low-income grants up to $10,000 with no homeowner match required
- Premium reductions of up to 50% for homes with verified wind mitigation features
Eligible Improvements Include
- Impact-resistant windows and doors
- Hurricane shutters (permanent or removable)
- Reinforced garage doors rated for wind loads
- Roof-to-wall connection upgrades (hurricane clips)
- Roof deck attachment improvements
- Secondary water resistance barriers
- Impact-resistant roof coverings

To qualify, your home must be a single-family, site-built residence with a homestead exemption, insured for $700,000 or less, and built before January 1, 2008. Applications are accepted on a first-come, first-served basis through the official portal at MySafeFLHome.com.

Understanding Your Florida Insurance Coverage Options

Florida’s insurance landscape involves several different types of coverage. Understanding what each policy does — and doesn’t — cover is critical before you close on a home.

Homeowners Insurance (HO-3 Policy)

This is your standard policy. It covers your dwelling, personal property, liability, and additional living expenses. In Florida, most HO-3 policies include windstorm coverage, but they typically have a separate hurricane deductible ranging from 2% to 10% of your dwelling coverage. For a home insured at $250,000 with a 5% hurricane deductible, you’d pay $12,500 out of pocket before coverage kicks in during a named storm.

Flood Insurance

Flood damage is NOT covered by standard homeowners insurance. You need a separate flood policy, either through FEMA’s National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) or a private flood insurer. If your home is in a FEMA-designated high-risk flood zone, your mortgage lender will require it.

Citizens Property Insurance

Citizens is Florida’s state-created insurer of last resort. If you cannot obtain coverage from the private market, Citizens may be your option. Citizens is recommending a statewide average rate cut of 2.6% for 2026, with three out of five policyholders seeing an average decrease of 11.5%. However, Citizens coverage is typically more limited than private market options.

7 Smart Ways To Lower Your Homeowners Insurance Costs in Florida

- Upgrade your roof. A new, code-compliant roof is the single most impactful thing you can do. It makes you insurable and can dramatically reduce your premium.
- Install impact-rated windows and doors. These qualify for wind mitigation discounts and are eligible for My Safe Florida Home grants.
- Bundle your policies. Carrying homeowners and auto insurance with the same company typically earns you a multi-policy discount.
- Raise your deductible strategically. Increasing your hurricane deductible from 2% to 5% can lower your annual premium significantly, but make sure you can afford the out-of-pocket cost.
- Maintain a clean claims history. Filing even one claim can increase your premium by $1,600+ per year. Avoid filing small claims whenever possible.
- Improve your credit score. Florida insurers can use credit in their pricing. A good credit score can save you over $1,200 annually compared to poor credit.
- Shop every year. With 17 new carriers in the market, the competitive landscape is shifting. An annual insurance review with an independent agent can uncover savings.

What This Means for Home Buyers in Southwest Florida

The bottom line: getting homeowners insurance in Florida in 2026 is still harder than in most states — but it’s significantly easier than it was in 2023 or 2024. The combination of legislative reforms, new market entrants, declining litigation, and a quiet 2025 hurricane season has created real momentum.

If you’re buying in Cape Coral, Fort Myers, Naples, Punta Gorda, or anywhere in Southwest Florida, insurance needs to be part of your buying strategy from day one. Don’t treat it as an afterthought. Start getting quotes early, work with an independent agent, prioritize homes with updated roofs and wind mitigation features, and budget for both homeowners and flood coverage.

The market is heading in the right direction. Rates are stabilizing. Competition is increasing. State programs like My Safe Florida Home are putting real money toward making homes more insurable. And major carriers are filing for rate reductions — not increases — for the first time in years.

Your next step? Connect with a local real estate agent who understands the Southwest Florida insurance landscape and can guide you toward properties that are positioned for the best coverage and the lowest premiums. If you’re looking for a home in Southwest Florida and want expert guidance through the entire process — including navigating insurance — visit AgentsGather.com to connect with experienced local agents who know this market inside and out.

Frequently Asked Questions About Homeowners Insurance in Florida

Is it hard to get homeowners insurance in Florida in 2026?

Getting homeowners insurance in Florida in 2026 is challenging but improving. Legislative reforms have attracted 17 new insurers to the state, and rate increases have slowed to under 1% for major carriers.

https://agentsgather.com/homeowners-insurance-florida-how-hard-is-it-to-get-in-2026/