Downfall of Vacation Rentals by Owner

The Downfall of Vacation Rentals by Owner: Is It Still a Good Investment in 2025?

Over the past decade, vacation rentals by owner (VRBOs) exploded in popularity, fueled by platforms like Airbnb, VRBO, and Booking.com. Homeowners in vacation hotspots could generate impressive returns by renting out their properties short-term to tourists. But as we move through 2025, the landscape is shifting—and not all signs point to continued growth. Rising regulations, market saturation, and changing traveler preferences are forcing investors to reconsider whether this once-lucrative model is still worth it.

Let’s take a closer look at the current state of the vacation rental market, the challenges owners now face, and whether it’s still a viable investment path going forward.

What's Fueling the Decline of Vacation Rentals by Owner?

Tightening Local Regulations

Cities across the U.S. and abroad are cracking down on short-term rentals. In 2025, major metros like New York, San Diego, and Honolulu have implemented tighter restrictions:

Licensing requirements and caps on the number of nights rented

Zoning limitations prohibiting STRs in residential areas

Hefty fines for unregistered or non-compliant operators

These laws are designed to protect housing inventory for locals and curb the impact of overtourism, but they also make it much harder and more expensive for owners to operate legally.

Oversaturation in Tourist Markets

Vacation rental hotspots—think Orlando, Scottsdale, Joshua Tree, and Gulf Coast towns—have seen a massive influx of new listings in recent years. The result?

Increased competition

Declining occupancy rates

Price wars among owners

In 2025, many owners report lower revenue per booking and longer vacancy periods, making it harder to cover costs or justify holding onto high-priced properties.

Rising Costs and Inflation

Vacation rental owners are now dealing with:

Soaring property insurance premiums, especially in hurricane- or wildfire-prone areas

Higher utility bills, cleaning fees, and turnover costs

Increased taxes, including hotel/lodging taxes now applied to STRs in many markets

These costs can quickly eat into margins, especially if nightly rates are already being undercut by nearby competition.

Changing Traveler Behavior

In the early days of remote work, travelers were booking longer stays and looking for unique homes. In 2025, travel is still strong, but:

Guests are demanding more: better amenities, hotel-like service, flexible cancellations

Travelers are returning to hotels for convenience, reliability, and loyalty rewards

Work-from-home perks are shrinking, reducing long-stay demand

In short, owning a vacation rental today requires more effort, more service, and often more investment to keep guests happy and earn strong reviews.

💸 Is Vacation Rental Ownership Still Worth It in 2025?

It depends on your location, strategy, and goals. Here's a breakdown of what still works and what to watch out for.

Situation
Outlook in 2025
Unique or luxury property in high-demand market
Still viable with excellent management
Standard home in oversaturated tourist area
High risk, lower returns
Owner-occupied STRs (e.g., renting guest house or basement)
Often sustainable with low overhead
Heavily mortgaged investment properties
May struggle under pressure from rates and regulation
STRs in regulation-friendly markets
Stable, but increasingly rare

Alternatives and New Investment Strategies

If you’re considering a short-term rental investment—or reevaluating an existing one—here are updated strategies many investors are turning to in 2025:

Mid-term rentals (30+ day stays for remote workers or traveling nurses)

Long-term leases with stable monthly income and lower turnover

Buy-and-hold properties in markets with strong job and population growth

Fractional or co-ownership models to reduce exposure and risk

Multi-family properties that offer a blend of rental options

Vacation rentals can still be part of your portfolio—but they’re no longer the easy cash flow generators they once were. Strategic planning and hands-on management are now essential.

Vacation Rentals By Owner

The dream of making easy money from short-term rentals is fading in many parts of the country. With new regulations, high operating costs, and a cooling demand in oversupplied markets, investors need to think twice before jumping in. That said, vacation rentals aren’t dead—they’re just evolving.

For those willing to adapt, focus on service and experience, and stay ahead of changing rules, there’s still room to succeed. But in 2025, buying a vacation rental by owner without doing deep due diligence is riskier than ever.

https://agentsgather.com/downfall-of-vacation-rentals-by-owner/